Skip to content

Where to eat in Palmyra

13 independent restaurants, bakeries and food spots in Palmyra. Chains are left out.

Ranked with the travel guide's picks and well-known places first.

Where to eat in Palmyra

  1. Eat

    Muddy Waters Cafe

    A little cafe with sandwiches, salads, bakery items, and coffee. Nice view of the marina.

    Closed · opens 7 am tomorrow

  2. EatChinese restaurant

    Happiness Garden

    China Garden

    Classic Chinese-American eatery with takeout and delivery, but only two tables. Fairly good reviews.

  3. Eat Not mapped

    Akropolis Family Restaurant

    Extensive diner-style menu with a handful of Greek- and Italian-American dishes, including pizza. Breakfast is served all day.

    Closed · opens 7 am tomorrow$6-17

  4. Eat Not mapped

    Mark's Pizzeria

    Mark's has dozens of locations throughout the Greater Rochester metro (and beyond!), but it got its start back in 1982 right here in Palmyra. Sadly, the original, historic building, along with three adjacent ones, burned down in May 2013. But Mark quickly bought 'em all up and rebuilt a bigger store, one that's still in keeping with the historic architectural character of downtown Palmyra. Is it the best pizza you'll ever have? No, but it's good, as is the rest of the extensive menu, and they'll deliver just about anywhere.

    Closed · opens 10 am tomorrow$5-10

  5. Eat Not mapped

    Nima's Pizza

    Nima's is the other good pizza option in town if you don't like Mark's. Their pizza has a thinner style than Mark's, but Nima's real specialty is their calzones, which earn raves from patrons.

    Closed · opens 11 am tomorrow$4-10; delivery $1 w/in 5 mi, $2 beyond

  6. Eat Not mapped

    Chill and Grill

    While the 'grill' portion of this shop offers basic burgers, hots, and fries, it's the 'chill' side that draws in the locals in droves. Enormous ice cream cones are the specialty here.

  7. Eat Not mapped

    Yellow Mills Diner

    Good online reviews for this homey diner. Food is considered good for the price.

  8. EatBreakfast restaurant

    Akropolis

    Canal Street

    Limited wheelchair access

  9. EatRestaurant

    Cafe Aqueduct

    201 E Main St

  10. EatBarbecue restaurant

    Black Hart BBQ

    623 E Main St

  11. EatPizza restaurant

    Nimas Pizzeria

    165 E Main St

  12. EatGastropub

    The Hog & Hen

    201 E Main St

  13. EatRestaurant

    Tas-geo Of Palmyra Inc

    513 Canal St

Listings from the Wikivoyage guide to Palmyra (CC BY-SA 4.0). Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors (ODbL). Place data from Overture Maps.