Eat

Muddy Waters Cafe

A little cafe with sandwiches, salads, bakery items, and coffee. Nice view of the marina.

Updated 28 Sept 2026. Something wrong? Tell us.

No exact location on record.

More in Palmyra

Eat Not mapped
Akropolis Family Restaurant
Extensive diner-style menu with a handful of Greek- and Italian-American dishes, including pizza. Breakfast is served all day.
Mon-Thu Sat 7AM-9PM, Fri 7AM-10PM, Sun 7AM-3PM$6-17
Eat Not mapped
Chill and Grill
While the 'grill' portion of this shop offers basic burgers, hots, and fries, it's the 'chill' side that draws in the locals in droves. Enormous ice cream cones are the specialty here.
Eat Not mapped
Happiness Garden
China Garden
Classic Chinese-American eatery with takeout and delivery, but only two tables. Fairly good reviews.
Eat Not mapped
Mark's Pizzeria
Mark's has dozens of locations throughout the Greater Rochester metro (and beyond!), but it got its start back in 1982 right here in Palmyra. Sadly, the original, historic building, along with three adjacent ones, burned down in May 2013. But Mark quickly bought 'em all up and rebuilt a bigger store, one that's still in keeping with the historic architectural character of downtown Palmyra. Is it the best pizza you'll ever have? No, but it's good, as is the rest of the extensive menu, and they'll deliver just about anywhere.
Sun-Thu 10AM-10PM, Fri Sat 10AM-midnight$5-10