EatRestaurant

The Hoagie Stop

Name: The Hoagie Stop
Address: 220 Allen St, Buffalo
Telephone: (716) 864-4459

No write-up yet. Been here? Tell us what makes it worth a visit.

Address: 220 Allen St
Phone: (716) 864-4459
Website: thehoagiestop.com (opens in a new tab)

Directions Suggest a nearby place

Place data in Overture Maps open data.

Updated 28 Sept 2026. Something wrong? Tell us.

Close by

BuyAllentown and the Delaware District
Mundy Cakes
This garishly decorated building, set incongruously amidst the party-bar district at the west end of Allen Street, is where you'll find Amanda Bernardini six days a week, whipping up a lovely spread of house-baked goodies that includes cinnamon rolls, an extensive line of gourmet specialty cupcakes, and a cookie selection crowned by the ever-popular Mexican Wedding Cakes. Grab-and-go is the usual procedure, but if you'd rather linger in these cheery, aromatic surroundings (perhaps on a cold winter's day over a cup of Tipico coffee), the dining room couldn't be more pleasant.
Tue Wed 10AM-6PM, Thu-Sat 10AM-9PM, Sun 11AM-7PM
DrinkAllentown and the Delaware District
Billy Club
A more relaxed alternative to the usual Allentown party bars and dives, catering to a decidedly older and more upscale crowd. Owners Jake Strawser and Dan Hagen claim to be going for a "modern speakeasy" vibe, a nod to the real-life one that operated in the basement of this same building during Prohibition. But in reality the sleek lines, pastel tones, minimalist decor, and spherical hanging lights say "midcentury" much more than "Roaring Twenties", a perfect match for the Mad Men-worthy range of top-shelf whiskey, bourbon, and Scotch poured here.
EatAllentown and the Delaware District
Billy Club
The chilled-out Billy Club is, simply put, a breath of fresh air on the west end of the Allen Street strip, otherwise dominated by party-hearty frat-boy pubs: situated in a bright and airy space in Noel Sutton's stunning Puritan Building, newly renovated after some four decades of vacancy. A small but expertly crafted selection of upscale pub grub is served up from the kitchen by head chef Scott Crombie — check out the "House Grind Burger" topped with arugula, pickled onions, and blue cheese; the hanger steak that comes dressed with braised onions and mini potatoes and drizzled in a blue cheese jus; and a yummy cheese and charcuterie plate — but the real highlight at Billy Club is the bar; see below.
Mon-Thu 5PM-1AM, Fri Sat 5PM-2AM$20-45
DrinkBarAllentown and the Delaware District
The Old Pink
Allen Street Bar & Grill
The dive-iest of the dive bars on the west end of Allen Street, the Old Pink was one of the main stomping grounds for Buffalo's punk, hardcore, and goth crowd in the '80s, and still looks the part today. Cheap beer plus a short menu of bar snacks including a killer steak sandwich in an ambience brimming with grungy character. And old habits die hard: on weekend nights, longtime DJs EVR and Dr. Know (sorry punkers, not the guy who plays guitar for the Bad Brains!) spin a diverse profusion of left-of-the-dial favorites.