Shy's Original Steak House
Consensus from those who make it this far off the usual restaurant circuit is that Shy's serves the best steak hoagies in Buffalo — enormous concoctions (one serves at least two) piled high with melted cheese, onions, peppers, mushrooms and other fixins, plus a gargantuan helping of meat that's finely chopped, perfectly seasoned with an ineffable secret sauce, and so juicy it drips from the bread. Jim's Steakout, Mike's on Bailey Avenue, even the Wegmans sub shop all pale in comparison. Drawbacks include the postage stamp-sized dining room (takeout is understandably a popular option) and service that, while unfailingly friendly, is sometimes slow.
- Address
- 690 Fillmore Ave.
- Getting there
- Metro Bus 4, 6 or 23
- Hours
- Open now · closes midnight tomorrow
Weekly hours
Mon 11 am–midnight (next day) Tue 11 am–midnight (next day) Wed 11 am–midnight (next day) Thu 11 am–midnight (next day) Fri 11 am–midnight (next day) Sat 11 am–midnight (next day) Sun Closed Read from the travel guide, which lists: Mon-Sat 11AM-midnight
- Price
- $10-15
- Phone
- 17168527497
Listing from Wikivoyage: Buffalo/East Side, CC BY-SA 4.0.
Also listed in Overture Maps open data.
Updated 15 Nov 2026. Something wrong? Tell us.