EatSouth Buffalo

Mr. Submarine

No write-up yet. Been here? Tell us what makes it worth a visit.

Address: 1977 South Park Ave.
Getting there: Metro Bus 16
Hours: Mon-Sat 11AM-11PM, Sun noon-10PM

Directions Suggest a nearby place

Listing from Wikivoyage: Buffalo/South Buffalo, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Updated 28 Sept 2026. Something wrong? Tell us.

Close by

DrinkSouth Buffalo
Nine-Eleven Tavern
Can you go to Nine-Eleven for the typical South Buffalo dive-bar experience? Sure, if you like: they've got a respectable selection of beers on tap, the friendly barkeeps pour a decent cocktail, and there's shuffleboard for a bit of fun. But what most people come here for are the wings: with a house recipe that's a variation on Smitty-style wings in which some detect notes of malt or apple cider vinegar, Nine-Eleven's name is a perennial contender in the age-old debate about who serves the best wings in Buffalo, and given the fierce tone said debate often takes and the sheer number of competitors vying for the title, the size and loyalty of its fanbase is nothing to sneeze at.
DrinkSouth Buffalo
Talty's
If all you want is a beer (or maybe a game of darts, pool or shuffleboard), Talty's will serve you just as well as any of the other Irish pubs in the old Triangle. But where this place distinguishes itself is with its event calendar: live music is a specialty, with open mic on the first Monday of each month and local rock, blues, and acoustic bands playing three days a week.
DrinkSouth Buffalo
The Blarney Castle
The Blarney Castle may not look like much from the outside (or from the inside, for that matter; decor is spartan and runs toward a mix of green construction-paper shamrocks and mounted deer heads), but it differentiates itself from South Buffalo's sometimes borderline-indistinguishable roster of Irish pubs with its signature drink, the Bloody Mary, which comes brimming with flavor and an indelible hint of spice. Aside from that, you'll find the usual roster of big-name beers plus the ubiquitous Guinness on tap, and 50¢ wings on Monday and Tuesday nights.
DrinkSouth Buffalo
The Pub
With a clientele that's resolutely local and an ambience that falls somewhere between sports bar and neighborhood dive, Avenue is a good place to go if you want a real South Buffalo bar experience without the grunginess that can sometimes entail. It's also a place to go if you like bar games to go with your drinks: the game room's stocked up with a pool table and multiple dartboards, and out back there's even a horseshoe pit and a sand volleyball setup. At the bar you'll find a decent selection of beers and mixed drinks served with a friendly efficiency — including a few craft brews from the likes of Great Lakes and Southern Tier, but nothing too outlandish — and a food menu where wings are the standout.