Skip to content
Buffalo
EatWest Side

Restaurante Mi Isla

The "isla" in question is, of course, Puerto Rico, and you'll find the cuisine thereof well represented on the menu, especially if you like mofongo — the mashed-plantain dish is one of the harder-to-find boricua specialties in Buffalo, yet Restaurante Mi Isla serves about ten different varieties. Whether that or another item on the menu, prices are a bit hefty but so are the portions, and anyway you're getting in return some of the most authentic homestyle Puerto Rican food in town, with service to match, so don't feel guilty about splurging a little bit. About the only problem is the menu itself: it's written entirely in Spanish, so if you're a monolingual English-speaker, be prepared.

Address
74 Herkimer St.
Getting there
Metro Bus 3, 5, 12 or 40
Hours
Closed · opens 10 am tomorrow
Weekly hours
MonClosed
Tue10 am–6 pm
Wed10 am–6 pm
Thu10 am–6 pm
Fri10 am–8 pm
Sat10 am–8 pm
Sun10 am–6 pm

Read from the travel guide, which lists: Tue-Thu Sun 10AM-6PM, Fri Sat 10AM-8PM

Price
$15-35

Listing from Wikivoyage: Buffalo/West Side, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Updated 15 Nov 2026. Something wrong? Tell us.