EatAllentown and the Delaware District

Colter Bay Grill

Along with the Towne, Gabriel's Gate, and a few others, Colter Bay is one of a dwindling rank of "old guard" Allentown eateries that has persevered relatively unchanged (despite new ownership and recent renovations) for decades. The place takes its name from a small bay on Jackson Lake in Yellowstone National Park, and indeed a Western theme manifests not only in the ski-lodge decor (wood panelling and mounted antlers abound) but also on a menu where sandwiches, burgers, and pub grub-style appetizers come with unique flourishes. Notable are the Elk Alley burger, which features a patty of the namesake meat topped with crusted goat cheese croquette and seasonal fruit jam, as well as Pepi's Run Poutine, an authentic take on the Canadian classic.

outdoors

Address: 561 Delaware Ave.
Getting there: Metro Bus 7, 11 or 24; Metro Rail: Allen-Medical Campus
Hours: Sun-Thu 11AM-2AM, Fri Sat 11AM-4AM
Price: $15-40
Website: colterbaybuffalo.com (opens in a new tab)

Directions Suggest a nearby place

Listing from Wikivoyage: Buffalo/Allentown and the Delaware District, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Updated 28 Sept 2026. Something wrong? Tell us.

Close by

DrinkBarAllentown and the Delaware District
Colter Bay
Colter Bay was one of the first places in town to tentatively dip its toes into the craft beer craze that would go on to take Buffalo by storm in the 2010s, and anyone who's ever been lucky enough to experience Blue Monk, the sadly-missed gastropub that launched Colter Bay's owner, Mike Shatzel, to local fame, knows what that means: there are some four dozen national and local microbrews on tap at the bar, as well as some craft ciders and house cocktails, all expertly mixed and poured in a refreshingly chill environment where the tightrope walk between hipster-friendliness and stifling pretentiousness is successfully mastered.
EatItalian restaurantAllentown and the Delaware District
Panaro's
Panaro's is a small, family-owned and operated Italian restaurant open weekdays for lunch, with a take-out window available through dinnertime. The menu is surprisingly diverse, with a dizzying range of sandwiches, focaccias, entree salads, pasta dishes, and homemade specialty pizzas offered. Panaro's slate of appetizers includes a pasta fagioli soup that is beloved by many locals, as well as one of Buffalo's best Caprese salads. The dessert selection includes Italian specialties such as cannoli, pasticotti, and cassata cake prepared in-house.
Mon-Fri 11AM-6:30PM (take-out only after 3PM)$10-20
SeeArt museumAllentown and the Delaware District
El Museo
El Museo has been open in Allentown since 1981, serving its mission of exhibiting contemporary works by artists of color. Its initial focus on works by Latino artists is complemented by representations of African, African-American, Asian, American Indian and Caribbean culture, in visual art as well as other media. El Museo presents six to eight exhibitions per year and is an excellent place to appreciate groundbreaking works created by emerging artists from the local area who reflect cultures that are traditionally underrepresented in the art world.
Thu-Sat noon-5PMDonation
BuyAllentown and the Delaware District
Allen Street Dress Shop
A purveyor of "beautiful clothing for interesting women", the Allen Street Dress Shop is the place to go in Allentown for creative and chic clothing and accessories at reasonable prices, from such brands as Kiko, Anthropologie, and Cut Loose, as well as by new designers on the cutting edge of fashion whose lines are displayed on the store's website.
Mon-Fri 10:30AM-6PM, first Fri of each month till 9PM, Sat 10AM-6PM, Sun noon-5PM