Skip to content
Buffalo
EatAllentown and the Delaware District

Colter Bay Grill

Along with the Towne, Gabriel's Gate, and a few others, Colter Bay is one of a dwindling rank of "old guard" Allentown eateries that has persevered relatively unchanged (despite new ownership and recent renovations) for decades. The place takes its name from a small bay on Jackson Lake in Yellowstone National Park, and indeed a Western theme manifests not only in the ski-lodge decor (wood panelling and mounted antlers abound) but also on a menu where sandwiches, burgers, and pub grub-style appetizers come with unique flourishes. Notable are the Elk Alley burger, which features a patty of the namesake meat topped with crusted goat cheese croquette and seasonal fruit jam, as well as Pepi's Run Poutine, an authentic take on the Canadian classic.

Address
561 Delaware Ave.
Getting there
Metro Bus 7, 11 or 24; Metro Rail: Allen-Medical Campus
Hours
Open now · closes midnight tomorrow
Weekly hours
Monmidnight–2 am, 11 am–2 am (next day)
Tue11 am–2 am (next day)
Wed11 am–2 am (next day)
Thu11 am–midnight (next day)
Fri11 am–4 am (next day)
Sat11 am–4 am (next day)
Sun11 am–midnight (next day)

Read from the travel guide, which lists: Sun-Thu 11AM-2AM, Fri Sat 11AM-4AM

Price
$15-40

Listing from Wikivoyage: Buffalo/Allentown and the Delaware District, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Location and details from OpenStreetMap, © OpenStreetMap contributors, ODbL.

Updated 15 Nov 2026. Something wrong? Tell us.