DrinkBarDowntown

Fattey Beer Co.

Buffalo Rising asks about Fattey: "Is it a bar? Is it a store?" The answer is: not only is it both, but it pulls off both roles with equal aplomb. Compared to what's available in the bottle shop, the on-tap selections at downtown's craft beer emporium skew more heavily toward local and regional beers rather than imports and West Coast varieties. But service is impeccable, the chilled-out and welcoming vibe is miles away from the usual beer-snob scene, there's free popcorn to nosh on, and the sidewalk terrace on Roosevelt Plaza is a nice al fresco alternative on warm days. If you find the selection overwhelming, they offer $10 flights; if you're on a budget, head for the vintage fridge filled with $3 bottles — and if beer isn't your drink, check out Fattey's almost-as-impressive selection of ciders and seltzers.

Address: 5 Genesee St.
Getting there: Metro Rail: Fountain Plaza
Website: fatteybeer.com (opens in a new tab)

Directions Suggest a nearby place

Listing from Wikivoyage: Buffalo/Downtown, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Location and details from OpenStreetMap, © OpenStreetMap contributors, ODbL.

Updated 28 Sept 2026. Something wrong? Tell us.

Close by

BuyDowntown
Fattey Beer Co.
When Blue Monk on Elmwood closed, the loss to the local craft beer scene was staggering. Sure, there's been an explosion of new breweries, bars, and bottle shops emerging in the intervening years, but none of them could match the Monk for sheer variety. That dark age ended in 2019 with the opening of Fattey Beer Company on downtown's Roosevelt Plaza, the brainchild of Nik Fattey, one half of the ownership team of Hamm & Fattey's in Hamburg. The selection goes far beyond the navel-gazing obsession with local brews that you see elsewhere around Buffalo: an enormous rotating roster of over 500 varieties, including some hard-to-find rarities, available to take home or to drink in the onsite bar. Simply put, if you're a beer snob, Fattey is a can't-miss.
Sun-Thu noon-11PM, Fri Sat noon-midnight
DrinkCaféDowntown
Overwinter Coffee
No fancy syrups or frou-frou cappuccinos at this tiny little place — just real honest-to-goodness coffee, light-roasted and smooth-drinking yet bold-flavored; a little pricey but you get what you pay for. And if you really like it (and really have money to burn), they ship the same house-roasted, expertly blended beans nationwide! Indoor seating is extremely limited, but if it's a nice day, take a seat at one of the tables set up on Roosevelt Plaza and enjoy your coffee al fresco; it's one of downtown's best people-watching spots.
Mon-Fri 7AM-3PM, Sat 8AM-2PM
EatRestaurant
Graylynn
537 Main St
EatSandwich shopDowntown
D'Avolio's Kitchen
The downtown location of this local chain of gourmet food shops also includes a restaurant with a menu of build-your-own salads, pizzas, antipasto plates, and sandwiches. Service is fast-casual style: you're given a laminate-surfaced menu board and a dry-erase marker, and you mark off your preferred ingredients (bread/pizza crust/salad base, one or two meats, one or two cheeses, veggie toppings, and condiments). A soup du jour and seasonal fruit bowl comprise the somewhat limited selection of appetizers and sides, and drinks include a wide range of hot and iced teas and a more modest selection of beer and wine. The food is prepared with time-tested Old World techniques that bring out the subtle flavors of the ingredients, and portions are large.
Mon-Fri 10AM-2:30PM$15-25