Skip to content

Where to eat in St. Marys

40 independent restaurants, bakeries and food spots in St. Marys. Chains are left out.

Ranked with the travel guide's picks and well-known places first.

Where to eat in St. Marys

  1. EatRestaurant

    Gunners

    This tavern offers an extensive menu with a number of creative steak, seafood, and pasta options. We're not talking fine dining, here, but good basic meat-and-potatoes food with the occasional interesting twist. The bar area is a popular hangout for locals, but the dining room offers seclusion from the noise. Casual atmosphere. Banquet hall downstairs; lodging upstairs.

    $6-24

  2. Eat

    Pfaff's Market

    The only full-service grocery remaining in the city limits, Pfaff's has been around a long time. It's a bit off the main drag, but it's a great alternative to Wal-Mart.

    Closed · opens 7 am

  3. Eat

    Giant Eagle

    Formerly a Bi-Lo, Pittsburgh-based Giant Eagle has moved in and provides a clean, well-lit store with plenty of selection and services.

    Closed · opens 7 am

  4. Eat

    Hoss's Steak and Sea House

    Chain steakhouse known for their Soup, Salad, and Dessert Bar. Lots of historic images of St. Marys in the decor.

    Closed · opens 11 am

  5. Eat

    Ricks Doughboys

    An excellent locally-owned pizza place, with hot and cold subs, wings, strombolis, and several pasta options as well. Good quality, prices quite reasonable. Housed in an expansive former apparel store, redecorated to showcase the owner's classic automobiles, which flank the entrance. A fair amount of seating is available, though most of their business is takeout.

    Closed · opens 10:30 am$4-10

  6. Eat

    Save-A-Lot

    The discount grocery chain offers super-low prices by cutting back on service and selection. They have meat and produce, but no deli department.

    Closed · opens 9 am

  7. EatRestaurant

    St. Marys Corner Restaurant

    202 Chestnut St

  8. Eat Not mapped

    The West Wind

    A nice little restaurant at the airfield; very popular among residents for special occasions. Pasta, seafood, and chicken wings are their specialties, but there are also some good steaks. You might also want to try the famous mile-high pork chops, a favorite from the restaurant's previous incarnation, the Silver Wing.

    $10-30

  9. Eat

    Diamond View Restaurant & Lounge

    >

    Apr-Nov: Grill Room 4:30PM-?, Upstairs 4:30PM-8:30PM; Nov-Apr: Grill Room noon-?, Upstairs 4:30PM-8:30PMGrill Room $4-10; Upstairs $9-25

  10. EatDonut restaurant

    Sugar Mamas Bake Shop

    424 Depot Street

    Wi-Fi

  11. EatAmerican restaurant

    Casali's

    32 South Saint Marys Street

  12. EatRestaurant

    Keystone Corner Lunch

    107 N Michael St

  13. EatChinese restaurant

    Green Jade

    226 Chestnut Street

  14. EatMexican restaurant

    Taco Inc

    239 Brusselles St

  15. EatRestaurant

    The Highlands

    535 S Michael St

  16. EatRestaurant

    Rick's Dough Boys

    228 Brusselles St

  17. EatRestaurant

    Don's Pizza

    320 South Saint Marys Street

  18. EatAmerican restaurant

    Marlos Place

    1223 Brusselles St

  19. EatDelicatessen

    Tablespoons Cafe and Deli

    10 Erie Ave

  20. EatBar & grill restaurant

    Wildwoods Bar & Grill

    875 Washington Rd

  21. EatBakery

    D D's Specialty Bakery Cafe

    31 Erie Ave

  22. EatBar & grill restaurant

    Dino's Place

    233 Market St

  23. EatIce cream shop

    Brandy Camp Creamery + Kitchen

    45 Erie Ave

  24. EatDelicatessen

    DeLullo's Deli & Car Wash

    19 John St

  25. EatPizza restaurant

    Fox's Pizza Den

    237 Market St

  26. EatAmerican restaurant

    Green Lite Restaurant & Lounge

    1221 Brusselles St

  27. EatRestaurant

    Tat Technologies

    106 Enterprise St

  28. EatGerman restaurant

    marienstadt public house

    424 Depot St

  29. EatSandwich restaurant

    Anytime Lunchtime

    306 State Street

    Closed · opens 11 amOutdoor seating

  30. EatRestaurant

    Cooper's Diner

    804 S Michael St

  31. EatRestaurant

    Funaki Management Llc

    33 S Saint Marys St

  32. EatRestaurant

    Rose's Hilltop Diner

    Million Dollar Hwy

  33. EatGastropub

    The Pour House Bar and Grill

    626 S Michael Rd

  34. EatBakery

    Storybook Sweets LLC

    148 Houston Rd

  35. EatSandwich shop

    Vito's Hoagie House

    201 Parade St

  36. EatPizza restaurant

    Merlin's

  37. EatPizza restaurant

    Buck's Pizza

  38. EatRestaurant

    ELKS CLUB

  39. EatRestaurant

    Foxes Pizza

  40. EatRestaurant

    Straub Visitor Center & Tap Room

Listings from the Wikivoyage guide to St. Marys (CC BY-SA 4.0). Map data © OpenStreetMap contributors (ODbL). Place data from Overture Maps.