Skip to content
Locrawl

Where to eat in Plymouth

15 independent restaurants, bakeries and food spots in Plymouth. Chains are left out.

Ranked with the travel guide's picks and well-known places first.

Where to eat in Plymouth

  1. Eat

    42 Degrees North Restaurant and Lounge

    Specializes in seafood with a separate "Fish Market Menu" that has a variety of fresh fish that can be prepared to your specifications. Also serves regular dinner fare such as beef, pasta, chicken, soups and salads. Outdoor deck open seasonally.

    Entree $15-30

  2. Eat

    Blue-Eyed Crab Grille and Raw Bar

    Fresh seafood specials changing daily with a choice of toppings. Also miso salmon, rib eye steak, grilled jerk brick chicken, salads and burgers. Indoor and outdoor seating. Lunch and Dinner.

    Sun-Thu 11:30AM–9PM, Fri Sat 11:30AM–10PMEntrees $12-45

  3. Eat

    Blueberry Muffin

    Cederville village's staple bakery and breakfast meetup spot. Also serves lunch.

  4. Eat

    Dillon's Local

    Family owned specializing in craft beer, cocktails, and locally-sourced food. Serves authentic Shepherd's pie! Voted Best Lunch Spot by South Shore Living 2017.

    Mon-Sat 11:30AM–1AM, Sun 10AM–1AMEntrees $12-26

  5. Eat

    East Bay Grille

    Well-appointed New England fare: seafood, steaks, chowders, and the like with a waterside view. Patio dining available. Business casual dress code.

    Entrees $22-42

  6. Eat

    Gellar's

    The unofficial "town hall" of Manomet, operated by the Gellar family since the 1920s. Most famous for its ice cream, but also serves sandwiches, seafood, burgers, and other lunch staples.

  7. Eat

    Lobster Hut

    Fairgrounds type atmosphere, casual but decent seafood a stone's throw from the sea. Eat inside or out. If out, beware of hungry gulls.

    Summer daily 11AM-9PM; winter daily 11AM-7PM$5-15

  8. Eat

    Mama Mia's Restaurant & Pizzeria

    Long time local Italian favorite. Probably the best pizza on the South Shore or Cape. Family friendly.

  9. Eat

    Rose and Vicki's

    Manomet's staple sub shop. Sandwiches, wraps, salads, pizza, bakery items, apps, party platters. Dine-in and delivery.

    Daily 9AM - 9PM

  10. Eat

    Rye Tavern

    Rural restaurant in historic tavern building, specializing in "farm to table" dining. Highly variable seasonal menu with exceptional food quality, more reminiscent of Nantucket than Plymouth. Beautiful gardens out back. Great place for a romantic date, and easily the most upscale restaurant in town. Taking a drive down Old Sandwich Road is an adventure onto itself; road follows an ancient woodland path that connected Cape Cod to the mainland in pre-Mayflower days.

  11. Eat

    Surfside Smokehouse

    American BBQ and seafood; great for lunch or dinner. Kid's menu. Open seasonally. Eat indoors upstairs or join the more casual bar scene on the outside deck downstairs. Nice views of the marina.

    Entrees $12-27

  12. Eat

    Water Street Cafe

    Winner of several Best Breakfast and Lunch awards. Large variety; homestyle feel.

    Daily 5:30AM-3PM

  13. Eat

    Wood's Seafood Market and Restaurant

    Fresh seafood in the rough with a fish market as well. Top notch clam chowder and fried whole clams made by Exec. Chef JMitch. Voted Editor's Choice for Massachusetts by Yankee Magazine's Travel Guide to New England.

    Daily 11AM-9PMEntrees $5-22

  14. Eat

    CJ's Bar and Grill

    Traditional American comfort food.

    Sun-Tue 7AM-1PM, Wed-Sat 7AM-9PM$15-30

  15. Eat

    Cafe Strega

    Authentic Italian restaurant overlooking Brewster Gardens.

    Entrees $15-38

Listings from the Wikivoyage guide to Plymouth (CC BY-SA 4.0).